Section 21: The Approval Your Advert Needs Before It Runs
This week, the panel is joined by Carly Nuzbach Lowery, Founder and CEO at Gateway 21.
Podcast Overview
Episode transcript
Amelia: Welcome back. Hi, I'm Amelia.
Paul: I'm Paul.
Amelia: And this is Fin the Week. Welcome back to the show, brand new episode. And I'm excited to say we've got a guest. We love having a guest. So, Carly Nuzbach Lowery from Gateway 21. Carly, welcome. So nice to have you on the show.
Carly: Well, thank you so much for having me. Pleasure to be here.
Amelia: So today we're going to be talking about Section 21 approvals, but before all of that, would you mind giving us the 30-second rundown intro? Who are you and what do you do at Gateway 21?
Carly: Absolute pleasure. So hello, I'm Carly Lowery. I'm the founder and CEO of Gateway 21. We are a finprom approver. I am, as you've probably already noticed, American, but I came to the UK as anyone would, in connection with the financial crisis. So I've been here for 16 years, focused on areas of contentious regulatory law. I did that in TradFi for a long time and then got into tech when all the companies like Uber and Coinbase started getting into trouble with regulators. And then I set up Gateway 21 specifically to plug the gap that I saw between where the regulator wanted finproms to be and where the market naturally was, particularly when they extended the perimeter to include crypto. So in 2023 we got authorised and we've been providing finprom approvals ever since.
Amelia: So for those of us who are unfamiliar, what does the work of a Section 21 approver involve? And for somebody who doesn't work in finance, like me, what is this all about?
Carly: Well, Amelia, get ready. It is by far the sexiest regulation. So Section 21 of the Financial Services and Markets Act creates what's called the financial promotion restriction, whereby if you would like to communicate an invitation or inducement to engage in investment activity in the course of your business, you must either be an FCA-authorised firm or have the approval of an FCA-authorised firm. So where a finprom approver steps in is that we are that authorised firm for firms who are not authorised.
Amelia: So that's it in a nutshell. How do you get approval as a firm? What is that process like?
Carly: It's a classic FSMA application. You have to actually be an investment firm in order to have this permission. So we have classic Regulated Activities Order-type permissions, Article 25(1), 25(2), and I won't go into those, not the topic of the day. But in addition to that, in 2024 the FCA created what they called the finprom gateway. And so for Part 4A firms who wanted to provide these Section 21 approvals, and you'll be shocked to hear there weren't many of us, you needed to pass through this gateway. You needed to request to maintain this permission and itemise for the FCA the asset classes for which you wanted to provide them. So we did that, and the rest is history.
Amelia: And on that note… sorry, go on, Paul.
Paul: Yeah, I was going to say, what's the typical type of firm who would approach a company like Gateway 21? For example, we work with a lot of offshore companies who maybe want to promote something in a market like the UK. The way they describe it is that they're technically allowed to promote a certain thing, but they're not approved. Is that the type of scenario where they would come to someone like you?
Carly: Absolutely. So the vast majority of our clients are offshore firms who have products and services that they can legally offer to UK consumers. They just can't really tell them about it. And that's the tricky part here. So offshore firms get their authorisation in their home jurisdiction, but then when they want to promote it into the UK, there needs to be a check that they are doing so in a way that is fair, clear and not misleading. And so where we actually sit is approving the communication, not the product or service. We take a look at each communication that firm wants to make, whether it's their website, whether it's a tweet storm or a LinkedIn ad, whatever they might come up with. We even have TikTok videos these days. And we enable them to make that communication into the UK in a way that meets the FCA's expectations. So coming back to the core of your question, Paul, a lot of our clients are offshore. And then we have a smattering of onshore firms who do things that are not caught by the Regulated Activities Order but are caught by the finprom gateway.
Paul: And when you're approving things, I'm just thinking about the day to day. Is a firm just firing, say, TikTok videos and LinkedIn posts at you and you're saying, "Yep, yep, that's fine," or is it a bit more strategic than that?
Carly: You'll be shocked to hear it's a little more strategic than that. But not always. It totally depends. The diversity of our client base is part of what keeps it so interesting, but it is also part of what makes it so that there's no typical day. On the crypto side in particular, we might have a single token wallet where all they want to do is tweet all day long. Or we might have a big, major exchange that has predicted, planned, extensive campaigns for things like BA in-flight ads. And so the way that they operate is quite different, but fundamentally the application of the requirements on our end is the same.
So our clients get access to a portal that we've created. We're a funny bunch. We have about 50-50 tech people and reg people, because we thought, if we're going to work with companies that want to move quickly, we should build our own software and let them know that we're doing this in a really tech-forward way. So all of our clients can log into the portal, fill in a little form, attach a copy of whatever it is that they want to say, hit submit, and it comes through to our team, who review it against typically 116 points of compliance, depending on the asset class.
To support that, we've built three AI assistants who focus on restricted mass market instruments, which is one of the trickier categories of assets to promote. And our clients get full, unbridled access to those assistants. There's a chatbot, there's one that tells you whether it's likely in or likely out, and then there's one that actually does the compliance review. So our clients have those toys. They can tinker around, take their best stab, send it through to us. It typically takes one or two goes to get it right. We are usually giving feedback, and that's fine, because part of the whole point of this is that we're there to be the experts who know all 116 questions that need to be asked, and our clients don't have to. So we give them the tools to get it as close as they possibly can, but we assume we're going to need to give them a little bit of feedback along the way.
Pat: So your clients use the portal, they go back and forth with the AI to refine the messaging, and then is there a final human guardrail check where one of your legal team formally approves it and says, "Yeah, that's fine, let's go"?
Carly: Exactly. The approvals always have to come through a human. We are at pains to remind people we are not their lawyers, we are their approvers. So it's our regulatory team who does it. But at the end of the day, the fair, clear and not misleading test is unbelievably subjective. We do our best with these 116 points to make it as objective, transparent and consistent as possible, both for our clients' benefit and for consumers' benefit. But at the end of the day, sometimes a human has to just look at it and say, "There's a bunch of rocket ships in the corner. Is that all going up? Is that giving the impression that this can only go up?" And so there is always going to be at least one, if not two, humans who look at it before an approval is given.
Pat: I know some of our clients try to publish stuff on Facebook or LinkedIn, but with Meta, for example, there are certain things that will just immediately flag you, so you need something like an FCA number. The AI will just flag these and it's "computer says no", and you hit a roadblock, even though, as you say, they're allowed to sell these products in the UK. Do you help your clients through these "computer says no" type interfaces? Do you give them an FCA number that they can enter to help them get their promotions published?
Carly: We come up against this all the time. And, at the risk of being philosophical, this is the reason why Web3 is so interesting, because these Web2 gatekeepers really do govern access to the internet right now, your Googles, your Metas, and they keep people from doing the work that they want to do, oftentimes based on a misunderstanding. So we get these distress calls regularly from clients. We say, "Don't worry," because we now have established relationships with some of those gatekeepers, where we can say, "You've got the wrong end of the stick. They're one of ours. Let them through." And we do that on a pretty regular basis.
Pat: So you can actually phone Google. That's a rare benefit, isn't it?
Carly: To find that guy at Google who is the actual gatekeeper and able to unlock it, it was quite a process. And he will not let me utter his name or share his email with anyone, lest he be deluged.
Amelia: We were just about to ask.
Pat: Yeah, you can email his details to me later.
Carly: Exactly. No, but he's been great, and it's good to know that there are good and sensible people in all these places. You just have to find the right route in and help them to understand the regulation as well, because it isn't a straightforward regulation. It's not rocket science, but it's incredibly tedious.
Paul: Something I find interesting as well, speaking to some of the people we've worked with in the past, is that we will speak to, say, the marketing team, and presumably behind the scenes they'll have a compliance team as well. And I'd imagine the compliance team know about this. Even if they're an offshore firm, they'll still understand what the FCA is looking for. But in my experience, the marketing team hasn't been briefed on this, and so hits the wall of trying to run a campaign on, say, Meta, can't get the ads running, feels like that's a dead end, and gives up. In your experience, is it because people just don't know about Section 21 and firms like yours? How well known is this?
Carly: It's a real mix. I think you guys tend to deal with firms who will at least have a compliance department. Increasingly, we're seeing finfluencers, or just agencies that are working with a number of different companies, and they have no compliance department. They have no exposure to regulation whatsoever. And so this does come as a bit of a shock. In fairness, it's weird, right? Everybody needs to have some fine print. Whatever jurisdiction you go to, we all know your capital is at risk. But having to have that intermediary-level review by an FCA-authorised person is really foreign to most folks. And the FCA doesn't publish who actually has this permission.
Amelia: I was going to ask this. How would someone find someone to do this for them, then?
Carly: These days, go ask Claude or ChatGPT, and they will both tell you Gateway 21.
Pat: You did very well on your GEO there.
Amelia: Good plug.
Carly: I can tell you, the day the AI tools found us was a good day, and it was noticeable. It was genuinely noticeable. Because the FCA do not put out a list. We know that prior to the implementation of the financial promotions gateway, there were genuinely tens of thousands of firms who could do this work. And that dropped to around 100. And that's 100 across all asset classes. So we have permission with respect to 15 different asset classes. Most approver firms have two or three. So, for example, with respect to CFDs, I haven't found a single other firm who can approve for CFDs. We know of two other firms that can approve for crypto. And that's it. And there's no list. So it's very much a case of asking the AI or doing your Googles and hopefully stumbling across us.
Amelia: Why doesn't the FCA publish that list? What's the reason there?
Carly: Great question for the FCA.
Pat: Do they not like it?
Carly: The way that the FCA register works is you can go onto the FCA's website, you can search for a firm, and you can see their permissions. I understand why you would do it in that way as a regulator. I think they don't ever want to be seen to be endorsing or promoting. There are also circumstances where maybe some things aren't going quite right and someone's going to be coming off a list or losing a permission, or there are restrictions being put on it. And so they do it in reverse. You find the firm and then check the permissions, as opposed to providing lists of who has what permission.
Amelia: You've spoken about what approving a promotion involves, but what does it commit you to? So if it runs and it's wrong, where does the liability land?
Carly: Ooh. Well, I'll leave the liability question, strictly speaking, for the lawyers who still act like lawyers, and I'll tell you how it typically plays out. We let the FCA know when we have particular categories of high-risk clients join us. That way, if they see something that they think isn't quite right, they just write us a letter. So we get an email that has a little letter or a note inside it that says, "Hi, we've noted that you have approved such-and-such promotion. We're not sure that it complies with this section. Please can you go back, or can you tell us how you got comfortable?" And we take a look. And if it needs updating, we say to the firm, "Hey, we've had a letter from the FCA." Well, we typically tell them regardless. But we often say this could be tweaked or that could be better. It is such a subjective test that it's very rare that it's a black or white issue. Touch wood, my team has to date not overlooked some glaringly obvious problem in any finproms.
But what we do see is a little bit of subjectivity. This could be refined. Or genuinely we've had letters that say things like, "This shade of blue for the risk warning is insufficiently prominent in contrast to the underlying shade of blue of the overall website."
Amelia: Really? That specific?
Carly: Oh, the font size we get pulled up on. "Is this font size really the average across the entire promotion?" Yes, it is. We check that every time. Bolding and underlining that are required. It's very tedious. And so it's very easy to have these little trip-ups, but we tend to be able to work it out. We're pretty pragmatic, but we also have a great relationship with the FCA, so we can have that dialogue rather than somebody just getting slapped with a "you're in trouble" letter.
Pat: You'll be glad to hear I just asked Claude for some advice and it recommended you guys first. So, yeah, win.
Carly: There it is. At the risk of just talking about my firm, I don't know of anyone else who just does this. When I was setting up the firm, people looked at me like I had three heads, because who would want to just do finproms? But I really saw it as an opportunity. Having been a general counsel, where you get 10% of the time that you want to apply to any one matter but you still have to do it anyway, to move away from that in-house role and just take one thing and have the luxury of gold-plating one regulation. For me, that has been an absolute delight. And for my team, who are on the younger side, starting out in their careers but terribly, terribly smart, they get that luxury of knowing it inside and out, and within a span of 12 to 18 months becoming genuine specialists in an area of regulation where there aren't many in the UK. So wherever they go on to further in their careers, and I tell them they're never allowed to leave, but I'm realistic that I have incredibly bright, ambitious people working for me and they're going to someday need some other regulations to play with, they get trained up in a really great way on that one regulation.
And now, three and a bit years in, we're moving into some other regulations. The regulator has gifted us with a whole new regime for cryptoassets starting from October 2027. And we've got some new stuff coming out there.
Amelia: And we are going to get into that in just a little bit. But first, I wanted to know how your work relates to the FCA's three investment marketing categories. Can you talk us through that?
Carly: So are we talking about readily realisable securities, restricted mass market instruments, and non-mass market investments, NMMI?
Amelia: Yes.
Carly: As a general matter, we deal with readily realisable securities and restricted mass market instruments. When the FCA was undertaking the wholesale review that they did a few years ago of the finproms regime, they created these three categories of risk, and they basically said all of these financial instruments that can be promoted have a defined financial instrument category. It's a security, it's a future, it's a cryptoasset. But it also should have a risk categorisation. And that risk categorisation then dictates what the requirements are when you're communicating about it. So the 116-point checklist that I mentioned applies specifically to restricted mass market instruments. And then we have slightly lighter-touch versions for readily realisable securities or some of the insurance products that we work with. They're typically a subset of that RMMI list, but you can be a little bit lighter touch when it's a more, as it says, readily realisable instrument.
Amelia: And what about… sorry, go on, Paul.
Paul: I was going to ask as well about something you mentioned when we spoke a while ago, Carly, about the FCA's four positive frictions. I read into that and, while I can't say I'm an expert in any way, it was interesting because in the world of UX and what we do, we've discussed friction in the past. Do you want a certain level of friction in a system that's quite important? And I guess is that what the FCA is getting at with what they've described as these four positive frictions?
Carly: Yes, the short answer is yes. When I have to explain these, and I will get into what they are in just a moment, you can imagine the looks on product people's faces and UX people's faces when I say, "You're going to need to implement these four frictions." "No, no, no. Our whole job is to make the experience frictionless." No, no. The regulator's job is to actually add a little bit of friction.
So what the FCA decided was that in connection with what are called direct offer financial promotions, so it's not just a communication that invites or induces, it also comes with a mechanism of response. It's usually a "buy now" button, a "buy", a "trade", something like that. It's a mechanism for the consumer to immediately put their funds at risk. And what the FCA saw, with respect to cryptoassets in particular, because that was the impetus for a lot of these revisions, was a kind of impulse buying, a little bit of FOMO: "Ooh, people are buying the dog token." And they wanted to slow people down and say, "Just think for a second before you put your funds at risk."
And so what they came up with, in connection with those direct offer financial promotions, was these four frictions. There's a 24-hour cooling-off period, a personalised risk warning, a client categorisation exercise, and an appropriateness assessment. The first time that a consumer wants to put their funds at risk through one of those mechanisms, like the buy button, they must first travel through those four consumer journeys. They are the bane of the existence of many, many product people. What we have seen is that they have broadly done what we think the FCA wanted, which is slowed people down. And candidly, kept some people out. So if you couldn't get through, or you couldn't wait 24 hours, many people just abandoned the whole exercise of buying the token. They may or may not have come back another time. But what we have seen, and we've talked a lot with our clients, is a considerable drop-off in new consumers getting involved in trading in those assets since the introduction of those four frictions.
And yes, they're absolutely shocking to people when they first come to it. "You want to create friction?" But they are designed to give people a moment to pause.
Pat: It makes sense, though, doesn't it? When you think of it with a UX hat on, you think, what a nightmare. You're devastating the conversion rate, you're devastating the pipeline, you're deliberately losing customers. But on the flip side, people do need to stop if they're dumping a grand into some new meme coin, because it's probably going to be a pump-and-dump scheme, isn't it?
Carly: Well, I couldn't possibly say "probably".
Pat: It could easily be a pump and dump, couldn't it?
Carly: There are plenty of them out there. But for that first-time engagement, there's no reason why you need to do it within 24 hours. Now, the flip side is, Bitcoin has performed tremendously over the past however many years. And actually, if you look at it, maybe lots of people have been kept out of a very, very good investment. And I'm not sure that equates to consumer protection, because there are lots of things you could have dumped your money into that would not have given you the returns that certain tokens would have done. Now, Bitcoin is clearly quite an outlier in the crypto sphere, but they are all painted with that same brush in terms of those four frictions requirements.
Pat: Interesting. In terms of talking about crypto a bit more, obviously there's huge demand for your services in the crypto space. Crypto is massive. People are looking to promote all sorts of crypto schemes. So what proportion of your clients are in crypto, and out of those crypto clients, how many come to you with this incredible offering, they know what they're doing, they understand the regulations, they understand the back and forth, and how many are just kids who have spun up their own meme coin and are like, "Yeah, we want to do this GTA 6 meme coin, let's go"? Just jumping on the latest hype bandwagon. I'm interested, as someone who's in the industry, to get that kind of feel for it.
Carly: Absolutely. So, first question, what percentage? It is quite high, but it is decreasing, which is a really fascinating time for us. I would say over 90% of our clients right now are crypto. That is very much related to the fact that there are only three of us in the industry who can do crypto finprom approvals. And that was my background coming into it. I tailor-made this for the purposes of providing the service to crypto.
What we are increasingly seeing is that since the closing of the gateway, folks in the traditional asset classes have been left without any other options and they don't know where to turn. So we've now taken on futures clients, we have insurance clients, we have a pension client. Increasingly, we're seeing unlisted shares as a really, really interesting asset class for this. People doing primary offerings under the new POP licence, pre-IPO shares. So we are seeing an increase in the non-crypto sphere. That's also related to crypto starting to offer TradFi instruments. So, who's a good example? Both OKX and Payward. Payward is the parent company of Kraken, who also now have a futures exchange called NinjaTrader. So you see tokenised shares, which are still shares, being put on platforms that were traditionally crypto but now are categorised as traditional instruments.
In terms of how many cowboys we have knocking on our door, I would say fewer than you would expect, and that is not by accident. They don't care about compliance, and they're not going to come and pay for someone with very strict due diligence requirements to look at their marketing materials. They just bypass the whole thing entirely. I don't know what they're doing, but they are not working with us. We have a very self-selecting group of clients who actually want to do things properly. They might not know exactly what they have to do, but they definitely have the will to do it.
Pat: Yeah, interesting.
Amelia: And there are changes when it comes to cryptoassets in 2027. Talk us through that.
Carly: This is full-blown licensing. I think it's very easy not to appreciate, if you're not doing this every day, that currently in the UK there are only two regulatory regimes that apply to crypto: the AML regime, so anti-money laundering, and the finprom regime. Other than that, it's broadly unregulated.
What we see from the 25th of October 2027 is cryptoasset activity, so buy, sell, trade, lend, custody, stake, all the good and the great, will come, to varying degrees, within the regulatory perimeter, and you will have to actually get a licence. All these crypto firms will have to go to the FCA and apply for a Part 4A authorisation. Which is really interesting for our business, because it means they won't need us anymore. But don't worry, we have lots of technology that they can still keep plugged into. So rather than sitting under our regulatory permissions, they just use our software.
Amelia: So is this essentially meaning that cryptocurrency is going to be regulated much more like traditional financial services? Is that what it means?
Carly: Exactly. When you think about regulation, I think lots of us tend to talk about the thing, like "crypto being regulated", but really it's a two-part equation. It's an activity and it's an instrument. I can keep cryptocurrency in my wallet at home and I don't need a licence. But if I start holding my friends' deposits, that activity is a regulated activity. And so the activities that you might undertake with respect to crypto are increasingly coming within the perimeter.
Amelia: As we round off the conversation, if you had to summarise the aim of the Section 21 approver process, what was the original aim? And as far as you know, is it a success? I'm sure we can guess what the answer is going to be there.
Carly: You know, Amelia, it's a really interesting one. On the face of it, the aim is consumer protection. And there is absolutely no question that that is the regulator's aim, that that is our aim. Getting people the information that they need to make an informed decision before they put their funds at risk, that is the objective.
We touched a little bit earlier on the four frictions and whether those positive frictions have done what they were intended to do. And I think you really can argue it both ways, because there's no question, empirically, they have kept people out of crypto in particular. Query whether, big picture, that is a good thing. I think when you take it outside of the crypto question, it's definitely a good thing. We see increased consumer protection and information flowing to consumers every day, and that feels like a success for us.
Paul: On the point about the frictions keeping people out of crypto, that can definitely be a good thing and a bad thing, like you're suggesting. But the other thing I wonder is, how consistently do firms apply those frictions? It reminds me of how in the EU, car manufacturers now have to put in all of this technology that warns you if you're going over the speed limit, and automatic braking. But in my experience, if you drive a car by one manufacturer and a car by another, their implementation of it is actually quite different. Some cars are very strict about keeping you in lane, some aren't. Is it the same in this sphere, where one firm might be quite strict about how they're applying these frictions and another's very loose? And so the consumer at the other end maybe doesn't understand fully, they've just gone through a checkbox exercise. Is that a weakness, do you think?
Carly: Paul, that is a great question. What I would say is there is very little room for variation in the first three frictions. The 24-hour cooling-off period is what it is. The personalised risk warning is literally just, "Dear Paul Wood, you are about to put your money at risk. How would you feel if you lost all the money?" There's no real room. Same thing in client categorisation.
Where you see real variation is in the appropriateness assessments, because this is essentially a creative writing test. The firms had to go away and make up all these questions to test people's understanding of risk. And the FCA gave very few parameters around it, in terms of both the content of the questions and the structure of the test. How many questions? What's the pass rate? So at some firms you have to get 100%, at other firms it's 51% and you're good. There are 12 topics that should be covered, but it's not a rule, it's guidance. And so some firms mash them together and cover most of them, and some firms have vaguely plausible answers. When these were first rolled out, you should have seen some of the joker questions that we got. So in our view, that is where having a proper Section 21 approver makes a big difference, because we hold quite sensible but strong standards with respect to those appropriateness assessment questions. Keeping firms at the standard that we know the regulator would expect, that falls on us.
Pat: Can I ask you a Guernsey-specific question? When I bumped into you in the airport, Carly, a few months ago now, we talked a little bit about Guernsey. The GFSC have launched a virtual asset service provider licence, which in theory allows organisations to target retail customers directly. I don't understand the full ins and outs of it, but you were quite excited when I spoke to you about what the GFSC are doing in Guernsey. Is that still the case? Do you think Guernsey are taking the right approach? What's your view on it, as someone who's worked in businesses like Coinbase and Copper, who's right in there?
Carly: Look, I think it's fantastic. Markets hate uncertainty, right? Turmoil and lack of clarity just lead to chaotic markets. Giving the markets rules and regulations, they might not be perfect, but at least people know what they have to do and they can take a view. Is the juice worth the squeeze, as I hear in my industry all the time? And if you don't even know what the rules are, how can you run a business? So when I see regulators like you have in Guernsey being on the front foot and saying, "Look, we're going to take a stab at some regulations, we're going to roll them out quickly, we're going to give people some rules, but then we're also going to be sensible and pragmatic when it comes to licensing and revisiting them," for me, that's a dream. Because you can have consultations for years, you can debate how many eggs to put in the batter, but at the end of the day there's going to be a cake and everybody's going to have to eat it, and it's not going to be perfect. Let's just get it on the table and let people get started. It's that toing and froing that really inhibits a business being able to just know what's expected, take a view, and get it off the ground, or move elsewhere. So hats off to Guernsey.
Amelia: I think that's a great place to leave the chat. Carly, thank you so much. I think we've all learnt so much. It's been so nice chatting to you today. Before you go, would you fancy joining us in our game?
Carly: Always.
Amelia: So it's called Jargon Busters. Every week I give the panel a word from our list of industry terms to see if you know the definition, and who can give the best definition. I feel like we've had a tricky few weeks, and as we've got a guest, I thought we'd go quite straightforward this week. So, who can have a go at the definition for "blue chip"? Who wants to go first?
Carly: Ooh. It's one of those words that you know what it means, but do you really know what it means?
Pat: Can you articulate it?
Carly: What I wonder is whether there is a cutoff. Obviously, when you talk about a company being a blue chip company, it's an extremely reputable, probably high-performing company. I imagine at some point there was… now I want to know the history of the word.
Pat: Is it like top 100? Is it something as simple as that? Top 100 on the New York Stock Exchange or something? I don't know.
Carly: It's got to be something like that. But were there historically actual chips in different colours? That's what I would love to know. I bet there was.
Pat: Yeah, does that mean there are red chips and green chips? Amelia's searching it up now.
Carly: Tell us, Amelia, we're dying.
Amelia: I feel like you guys want more of an explanation than I've potentially got. So our definition here is: shares in a very large, well-established and financially sound company. Actually, it doesn't have to meet certain criteria, surprisingly. There's no official definition or qualification to become a blue chip company. So I guess it's more general than that. A bit subjective.
Paul: I feel like there's something in that chips thing, isn't there? The colour of the chips. It must be.
Carly: Feels like we're going to have a follow-up on this one.
Pat: Before this conversation, I definitely would have put the likes of OpenAI and Anthropic in blue chip, even though they haven't gone public yet. But now I think the financial stability question might rule them out of the blue chip conversation.
Amelia: Perhaps.
Carly: Time will tell.
Pat: Time will tell, yeah.
Amelia: Guys, thank you so much. Carly, thank you again for your time. We really appreciate it. And thank you, everybody, for listening. We will be back next week. Have a great weekend.
Paul: Yes.
Pat: Thanks, guys. Cheers.